June 14, 2007

Censorship in Liberal Germany?



As I was preparing for today's post about Hamburg, I noticed a commotion on Flickr. Flickr is the online photo platform I use to upload my Blog pictures. Maybe I should say "used to use"?


Here is what happened:



A photo was posted on Flickr that read: Think Flickr, think! Against Censorship!
This photo was all of a sudden uploaded by more and more people and the photo explanation read:

If your Yahoo! ID is based in Singapore, Germany, Hong Kong or Korea you will only be able to view safe content based on your local Terms of Service so won’t be able to turn SafeSearch off. In other words, German users can not access photos on flickr that are not flagged "safe" ... only flowers and landscapes for Germans ...Copy and upload this picture to your account - show flickr who we are!

Now, I am really surprised! Germany is one of the most liberal countries in the world when it comes to nudity. No, we don't run around naked all the time, but we have legal nude beaches. It is also very common for women to sunbathe topless even in public parks and advertising on TV and in magazines show partial nudity as no big deal. We are not talking porn here (which is also legal with certain age restrictions), but maybe partial nudity that is often shown in a very artistic way.


Why on earth is Flickr (or its parent company Yahoo!) censoring Germany? There are plenty of Photo Communities that do no censor legal photos. It certainly can not be against the law here, so why does Flickr / Yahoo! act this way?




Now you have some idea, how liberal Germany is in this respect and why I am so ticked off by this.

From now on, I will post the photos differently to the Blog. Maybe, if Flickr lifts the ban on Germany, I will go back to linking the photos from there.

But for now, I choose not to!

P.S. Thank you to the duck and the statue that were a perfect match for my little Photoshop work ;)


Yahoo! (the owner of flickr) has posted the storie in the Financial News:

http://biz.yahoo.com/ap/070615/flickr_censorship.html


This is Flickr's responds in their Blog and what others have to say about it:http://flickr.com/help/forum/42597/page5/#reply227666

7 comments:

Leticia said...

Considering that Fickr´s largest community is probably professional photographers, I find it strange they do that.

Anyway...I use gmail photo to upload to my blog. That way, if you don´t want it to be public, you still can have it private on your photo album but show it in your blog. :)

BillyWarhol said...

Hey thx for popping by!!

yeah Flickr Censorship Sucks!!

;))

Leticia said...

I came back to say hi...are you going to find another photo network for professionals instead of using Flickr?

Hugh W said...

bit quiet here
July BLOG ?

like your stuff on Flickr
now viesing as a slide show

"Moonlight om the Alster" is the title of a very old waltz

HughW36

IL RAMO RUBATO said...

Ciao dall'Italia... :) Molto interessante questo blog. A presto!

Jay said...

Hi there,

Nice stuff you got, fabulous pics.
Well, I do have also in my sleeves, if you have time don't forget to visit

photosorcery.com

Many thanks

Garagen said...

i use flickr too. i have bought an account and uploaded about 10,000 pics!!!